Skip to main content

Tanya Forster

Why Reassurance Doesn’t Work When Your Child Is Scared.

One of the most common misunderstandings I see parents have when it comes to their child’s fears is this: we focus on what they are scared of, rather than understanding what is happening in their body.

And when we understand anxiety, it completely changes the way we respond.

Anxiety is a body response, not just a thought

Years ago, when humans were faced with something stressful, it was often a real, immediate threat – like a tiger trying to attack us.

Our body would automatically shift into survival mode. Our heart rate would increase, our breathing would change, and our system would prepare us to either fight or run.

This response is incredibly adaptive. It’s what kept us alive.

The challenge is that while our world has changed, our nervous system hasn’t.

Today, we are far less likely to encounter a life-threatening danger like a tiger. But when we experience stress – worrying about work, finances, relationships – our body can still respond as though we are in danger.

In other words, our body reacts as if there is a tiger, even when there isn’t.

Your child’s “tiger” is real to their body

The same is true for our children.

Their fears might not always make sense to us. They might be scared of monsters, the dark, a storm, or being away from us. From an adult perspective, these fears can seem irrational or small.

But for a child’s nervous system, the fear feels very real.

Their body is not calmly evaluating whether monsters exist. It is responding to a perceived threat. Their heart is racing, their muscles are tense, and their system is preparing to protect them.

Their “tiger” might be different to ours – but to their body, it is just as real.

Why reassurance often doesn’t help

When our child is scared, our instinct is usually to reassure.

We might say:

  • “You’re okay.”

     

  • “There’s nothing to worry about.”

     

  • “Monsters aren’t real.”

     

We do this with the best of intentions – we want to comfort them and take their fear away.

But often, this kind of reassurance doesn’t work the way we hope.

That’s because reassurance is based in logic and reasoning. It’s a message for the thinking part of the brain.

When a child is in a state of anxiety, however, their nervous system is in survival mode. The brain is prioritising safety, not logic. The thinking part of the brain is much less accessible in these moments.

So it’s not that your child isn’t listening.

It’s that their body is trying to protect them.

Shifting the way we respond

When we understand anxiety as a body-based response, it changes the question we ask as parents.

Instead of asking:
“How do I convince them there’s nothing to be scared of?”

We begin to ask:
“How do I help their body feel safe?”

This might look like:

  • staying close and present

     

  • using a calm, steady voice

     

  • acknowledging their fear (“That feels really scary right now, I get it”)

     

  • helping them regulate through connection

     

These responses speak directly to the nervous system, rather than trying to override it with logic.

When we understand, we respond differently

As parents, we are always doing our best with the knowledge we have.

Reassurance comes from a place of care. It makes sense that we reach for it.

But when we begin to understand what anxiety actually is – a survival response in the body – we can shift our approach in ways that are far more effective.

We move from trying to fix the fear…

…to helping our child feel safe within it.

And that’s where real support begins.

x Tanya