“I Hate You!” When your kids say harsh words
“I hate you!”
“You’re the worst mum ever!”
“Go away!”
Ouch.
Few things hit quite as hard as hearing harsh words come out of your child’s mouth.
It can feel shocking and quite hurtful, and probably sometimes makes you think “AFTER EVERYTHING I DO FOR YOU!”
You might find yourself wondering:
“Where did you learn that?”
“Do you actually mean it?”
And probably even:
“I CANNOT let them speak to me like that!”
And while yes, it is true, it definitely feels shocking and they aren’t the words we would like to be hearing from our child, responding effectively in a way that actually helps means first understanding what is actually truly going on.
The good news
First of all, I think it is important to cover why these harsh words are actually a good sign.
Yes, you heard that correctly. There are actually a few reasons why these words can be a sign of something good.
First of all, these words actually occur commonly as a normal part of development. When kids are younger, they typically communicate their frustration through their body – hitting, kicking, and throwing.
When kids start to use these harsh words, as unpleasant as they are, it is actually a sign that your child is progressing through developmental stages. They are learning skills in regulation and impulse control. This is what allows them to use words rather than fists.
The second reason these words can actually be a good sign, is that often it is a sign of the strength of the attachment your child has with you. When your child feels safe, they feel able to let all those big feelings – and big words – out.
So each time your child tells you they hate you? Try smiling to yourself and repeating in your mind “Wow, my child must really feel safe with me!” It might not magically solve the moment, but it might just give you a chuckle along the way.
So what are these words actually all about?
Our kids do not yet have a fully formed adult brain. This means they do not yet have the problem solving, emotion regulation or communication skills we hope they will develop over time.
When they have all those big feelings? They do not yet have the skills to regulate them or express them effectively. The end result? They come out in some big words.
These words are a sign of our child’s overwhelm, disappointment, or frustration.
Their nervous system is activated. Their thinking brain is offline.
And what comes out?
Big, loud, reactive words.
Not carefully chosen language that articulates their concerns.
So do they mean it?
No. These words are an expression of how they feel inside, not about how they feel about you.
Those words are big, powerful and not very nice, and that is exactly how the feelings inside of their body feel.
They might be mad at you, sure. They might not like that you turned the TV off, took the iPad away, or told them they can’t have another cookie. But there is a big difference between that and actually hating you.
(To be clear, it also doesn’t mean you are actually a bad mum/parent!)
When they say “I hate you” —> they really mean “I hate how I feel.”
So what can we do about it?
Generally, our urge is to say “how dare you!” or “you cannot speak to me like that!” or “after everything I do for you!”
Of course that is our urge, that totally makes sense. It is natural to want to respond that way, it just isn’t actually very helpful.
So what is helpful instead? How can we respond in a way that actually minimises the chances of this happening again and again in the future?
- Regulate you first. Take a deep breath. Regulate your nervous system and bring your thinking brain back online. Those words can feel hurtful, so it is bound to have an impact. Our goal is to try and not take it personally, and instead look at the sentiment underneath the words. Deep breath.
- When your child is screaming “I hate you Mum. Do you hear me? I hate you!” We initially want to respond minimally. Remember, they are overwhelmed and their thinking brain is offline. We might say something as simple as “I hear you. I am right here.” Deep breath. Calm presence.
- We might want to try and contain and put a boundary around the words, just like we would stop our child if they were hitting. This might mean saying something like “Wow, they are really big words. You must be feeling really upset if you are saying that to me.” Depending on the moment, you might be saying something like “I know it feels hard when I turn the TV off/take the iPad away/say you can’t have another cookie.”
- Generally in these moments, our kids want us to understand how bad they are feeling. They aren’t sadistic or mean, they just want to feel heard and for us to truly understand how bad they feel. For some kids, it can feel really powerful when you say “It sounds like you are really upset about what happened, and when you say “I hate you”, maybe you want me to feel bad too so I understand how you are feeling.” Pause and hold.
- Coach when appropriate. Remember that when our kids are overwhelmed, their thinking brain is offline. Only once they are calm can we effectively engage them in reflective conversations that help them learn. When you feel it is appropriate, you might say something to your child like “It sounded like you felt really upset earlier. I wonder what you might be able to try saying instead next time?” Obviously the way you approach and the language you use will depend on the age and stage of your child, but helping your child to co-regulate, and then supporting them to reflect on what happened and think of what they might be able to do next time, is what helps to build the skills we are striving for.
- Pause and take a moment for yourself afterwards if you need to! These moments can sting, and they can be exhausting. While I want you to remember they are not a sign of you or your parenting, it is also very ok and very natural to find them hard. Don’t forget to take a moment for yourself when you need it.
I know these moments can be really tough.
They can feel personal, and they can definitely hit a nerve.
But they are also moments of learning.
When we respond with calm, connection and clear guidance, we start to teach our kids how to understand their feelings, how to express them safely and effectively, and how to repair when things go wrong.
So if your child has said something hurtful to you, you are not alone.
It definitely doesn’t mean you are a bad parent or that you have done anything wrong.
It means your child is still learning.
And with your support, they will get there.
x Tanya